The change of the gender marker implies a range of
problems – from the absence of special statutory provisions and procedures for making
documents compliant to the violation of rights of transgender citizens.
Currently, trans* people in Kyrgyzstan continue to be
denied the change of their gender marker in civil registry offices.
This is related to the fact that the law prohibiting
the change of the gender marker for transgender Kyrgyzstanis was adopted in
2020.
The previous
legislation of 2015 allowed this change.
The change
of documents for transgender people is one of the main levels of social
adaptation that allows them to get access to social and economic benefits, work
and education.
However, violation of rights of transgender people arises not only from
the new restricting law of the Kyrgyz Republic “On acts of civil status”, but
also from the absence of the procedure of personal identification number (PIN) change,
according to “KyrgyzIndigo” human rights organisations.
In 2018, a trans* man changed his gender marker from female to male in
the national identity card, when the previous law was valid. And when in 2022
he submitted documents to apply for the foreign passport, he received it with his
old marker, i.e. his sex was indicated as “female.”
This collision happened because the database automatically assigned his
“previous” gender to him because of the “female” PIN available in it. It is not
possible to change this PIN code so far.
PIN is a 14-digit code, where the first digit stands for gender assigned
at birth (1 for female, 2 for male). All PIN codes are stored in the State
electronic database, which is used for the issuance of passports and other
documents.
These codes are assigned to citizens by Civil Registry Offices once and
remain unchanged for life.
Nadira Masyumova,
consultant of the Coalition for Equality of the Kyrgyz Republic, said about
other negative consequences for the rights of trans*people, who have changed
their gender marker, but still have the same personal number.
“These
citizens cannot open bank accounts because when they complete a special
electronic form in the general database, the PIN code assigned to them identify
them as a person of another gender,” she said.
Another
violation of rights of the trans*man was reported when he was issued a Covid-19
vaccination certificate with the wrong gender marker.
Another case
happened to a trans*woman, who was in fact denied by the state in the change of
the gender marker, although it was performed legally previously. In 2019, she
changer the gender marker to female, but lost her passport. In 2021, she
applied to the public service centre, which delivers documents, and they told her
“the passport lost could be recovered only with the female gender.”
Commenting
on the situation, Nadira Masyumova indicated the unwillingness of the state to
take into account the needs and rights of trans*people, the existing
bureaucracy and high level of transphobia in the society. According to the
human rights defender, Kyrgyzstan has no potential for adopting the law that
facilitates the process of document change for trans*people in Kyrgyzstan so
far.
“There are
too many difficulties here,” she said.
This article was prepared under the project “Promoting Media Freedom and Diversity Through Reporting on Violation of Rights and Training of Media Workers in Creating Sensitive Media Reports on Minority and Marginalized Groups” with the support of the Canada Fund for Local Initiative (CFLI).